Standing Together: Barbara Kopple’s Harlan County, USA and Worker Solidarity

| Dan McCabe |

A man plays guitar in front of a crowd.

Barbara Kopple’s Harlan County, USA (1976) stands as a testament to the solidarity of the 20th Century labor movement. Live music plays a major role in the film.

Harlan County USA plays at the Trylon Cinema from Friday, November 27th through Sunday, November 29th. For tickets, showtimes, and other series information, visit trylon.org.


“They say in Harlan County,
There are no neutrals there,
You’ll either be a union man,
Or a thug for J.H. Blair,
Which side are you on?
Which side are you on?”

– Florence Reece, 1931

Florence Reece wrote “Which Side Are You On?” as an anthem for the “Bloody Harlan” coal strikes of the 1930s. That might surprise those who best know the Pete Seeger version from the late 1960s, or might associate the song with Barbara Kopple’s Oscar-winning documentary about the Brookside Strike of 1973, Harlan County, USA (1976). Reece herself appears in the film and performs her song to the exhausted miners. At that point in the film, the miners had not worked in months.

Before we descend into the mines, here’s your customary spoiler warning

Workers march in a street demonstration.

The striking miners demonstrate for better working conditions. Marches like this one did not occur as frequently as day-to-day picketing.

The State of Labor Since Harlan County, USA

The miners won the day in the Brookside Strike, but as shown in the last ten minutes of Harlan County, USA, their contract would soon get absorbed by the national United Mine Workers of America (“UMWA”) contract a few years later. This would walk back their right to strike at a local level, a key concession they won from Duke Power at the end of the Brookside Strike. Such was the reality of union decline in the second half of the Twentieth Century, a tale of lost concessions, lost faith, and corruption.

Unions have not disappeared entirely from American life, of course. Many public sector workers, film and television workers, auto workers, nurses, some professional athletes, and other occupations remain heavily unionized. Still, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, only about 10% of the American workforce is unionized. Contrast that to the 1950s, when nearly a third of American workers counted themselves as union members.

We can view Harlan County, USA from multiple perspectives. It partially documents some of the reasons for union decline from the 1970s to the present. Kopple shows this most prominently in a short digression away from Harlan County. She tells the story of Tony Boyle, UMWA President from 1963 through 1972. The Brookside miners at the local level complained about Boyle’s leadership to Kopple, describing him as feckless and corrupt, which would have been bad enough. Worse, Boyle was convicted in 1973 of ordering the murder of a rival union leader and his family. Anyone familiar with the story of union decline would know that this level of criminality cursed organized labor to many outside observers, and management used it as a tool to discredit union organizers.

Solidarity in the Face of Danger

Watching Harlan County, USA again after several years, I didn’t view it as only a sad tale of union decline. It remains a striking portrait of the power of solidarity. The mine workers go to the picket line without fail every day for months, despite the power of the company and the local government aligned against them. Despite legions of “gun thugs” hired to intimidate them, they continue to stand together.

During an evening picketing event, the company’s gun thugs open fire on the camera crew and the assembled demonstrators, who mostly consist of the miners’ wives. No one appeared to have gotten seriously hurt, but it’s hard for me to understate the sheer terror of a scene like that in a documentary. Real danger has an edge to it that even the highest-budget Hollywood blockbuster can’t truly simulate. 

A group of women block traffic.

The miners’ wives play a key role in the strike. Here, they block traffic and stand their ground in front of well-armed strike breakers and replacement workers.

The next morning, the miners’ wives return to block traffic, parking a car on a railroad track. This action prevents the company’s scabs (replacement workers) and enforcers from getting to the mine. The wives also have an arrest warrant for the leader of the company’s gun thugs. Kopple’s team helped with that one: they captured a still image of this man pointing a gun at the unarmed demonstrators the previous night.

Kopple’s Use of Music

Music plays a key role in uniting the mine workers by keeping their morale up. Union anthems such as Florence Reece’s had existed for a century, and Kopple makes sure to cut plenty of musical interludes into her documentary. Even when the women block traffic in the railroad showdown scene, they’re singing at the gun thugs lined up in their trucks. 

Note the word choice: singing at. While Kopple uses music in the film at appropriate times to add emphasis to scenes, like the opening rendition of Merle Travis’ “Dark as a Dungeon,” music in the context of the strike is a powerful tool of organization. Kopple shows several live performances in the film, which are no mere entertainment. Keeping morale high strengthens the bonds between the miners, which fuels the strike.

That’s not to say that the times Kopple uses recorded music to emphasize a point aren’t powerful. There’s a section of the film that discusses the dreaded “Black Lung” disease that affects coal miners and has greatly reduced their life expectancy. During one montage, the Hazel Dickens song “Black Lung” plays over the images. The pain in Dickens’s voice as she sings about the horrible disease helps Kopple’s film create an emotional connection between the plight of the mine workers and the audience. Kopple’s use of music is much like the miners using music to create solidarity with each other.

Of Solidarity and Idealism

Kopple portrays the camaraderie of the union in two other key scenes, both of which seem emblematic of the idealism of the 1960s, something that was fraying by 1976. The first scene takes place while the miners’ wives are picketing. A black miner is called a racial slur by one of the gun thugs, and the women stand up for him with ferocity. 

I’m certainly not naïve enough to believe that mid-century mining unions had completely egalitarian views on civil rights. I don’t think that’s what Kopple is getting at by emphasizing this interaction, however. I think she’s trying to show that differences that the mine barons could use to divide the miners can fade away with the unity shown by the mine workers. It’s idealistic, and that’s the point. I think Kopple chose to keep the interaction in the film to show the power of unity.

There’s also a moment when Kopple shows how the miners’ strong organization can inspire the members of other unions, even those who belong to that most controversial of unions: police benevolent associations. There’s a scene in New York City where the miners picket in the financial district to call attention to their struggle with Duke Power. One of the miners has a detailed conversation with a New York City police officer. 

The NYPD is mostly represented by the powerful Police Benevolent Association of New York, which has a history of delivering strong contractual benefits for its members. It also has a history of less savory activities, but that’s a topic for another day.1 My point in bringing them up, and possibly Kopple’s in alluding to them, is that the police officer the miner interacts with works under a strong union contract. The policeman seems genuinely surprised that the mine workers hope to get a contract with a fraction of the benefits that the PBA has negotiated with the City of New York. After all, coal mining and police work are both dangerous professions.

Kopple, therefore, presents two different kinds of interactions with law enforcement. One, on the streets of New York, is a conversation between two working people about union benefits. The other is what the miners experience back home in Harlan County, where law enforcement either turns a blind eye to the violence or actively supports Duke Power’s gun thugs. Recall the J.H. Blair from Florence Reece’s song? That is a reference to the anti-union sheriff that terrorized striking miners during the “Bloody Harlan” days of the 1930s.

If you strip away the support of the state and its monopoly on violence, beat-cops and coal miners have more in common than the people in power would want them to believe. Kopple hints at a world where the police would take the side of the miners as fellow workers and not the side of Duke Power.

A camera woman stands in front of a mine.

An exhausted-looking Barbara Kopple during the filming of Harlan County, USA. Kopple spent four years shooting the film.

When it comes to displays of solidarity of working people against the powers that seek to exploit them, Kopple doesn’t compromise. Harlan County, USA could have spent equal time examining and humanizing the business of coal, but not every documentary seeks even-handedness. Harlan County, USA is an argument for solidarity, not an academic survey of the economics of coal mining in the mid-twentieth Century. It remains one of the most powerful documentaries ever filmed, and it’s playing at the Trylon from November 27-29th.


 1The PBA has a history of defending police misconduct, and even organized the so-called PBA Riot of 1992.


Edited by Olga Tchepikova-Treon

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *